Apex Court orders SEBI to release investigation report: PEL analysis


The Legal Library section brings together quality and in-depth reports on regulatory developments, court decisions and policy changes written by India’s top law firms and consultants. These reports provide BloombergQuint subscribers with an opportunity to broaden their understanding of law and policy.

The Supreme Court of India has recently ruled that the Securities and Exchange Board of India is required to disclose the investigation report prepared by an investigating authority[underRegulation9oftheSEBI(ProhibitionofFraudulentandUnfairTradePractices)Regulations2003toapersonwhohasreceivedashowcause(advised)notice[underRegulation9oftheSEBI(ProhibitionofFraudulentandUnfairTradePractices)Regulations2003toapersonwhohasbeenissuedashowcausenotice(noticee)[envertudurèglement9durèglementSEBI(Interdictiondespratiquescommercialesfrauduleusesetdéloyales)de2003àunepersonnequiareçuunavisdejustification(avisé)[underRegulation9oftheSEBI(ProhibitionofFraudulentandUnfairTradePractices)Regulations2003toapersonwhohasbeenissuedashowcausenotice(noticee)

This was done because the report is “an intrinsic part of the Council’s satisfaction in determining whether there has been a violation of the regulations.”

This judgment is a welcome change because the regulator will now have to disclose its investigation report, barring exceptions. SEBI can no longer select documents for disclosure at the auction stage. The Supreme Court has ruled unequivocally that the test for disclosure is “relevance” and a simple ipse dixit from SEBI on this front will not suffice in the face of a party’s right to have the material used against it placed on the record.

In doing so, the Supreme Court put the regulator and the adviser on an equal footing by reducing information asymmetry in arbitration. However, it is likely that by leveling the playing field, this judgment paved the way for delaying tactics on the part of the noticees.

Click on the attachment to read the full report:


This alert does not constitute legal advice and is for informational purposes only. This report is written by an external party. BloombergQuint does not guarantee the accuracy of its content and is in no way responsible for it. The views expressed in the report are those of the authoring entity and do not represent the views of BloombergQuint.

Users have no license to copy, modify or distribute content without permission from the original owner.


Comments are closed.